Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

The 11 Best Apple Pies to Buy Right Now Via Mail Order

All products are independently selected by our editors. If you buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission.

One of the many joys of modern life is that yummy treats are just a couple of clicks away. We’ve curated a list of the 11 best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas. Or for just any day. Including March 14, which is Pi Day. Oh – and we’ve also got the inside scoop on the best ice cream by mail to put on top! See what we did there? Forks in the air, people. It’s pie time.

are mail order pies actually a reasonable substitute for homemade?

The wonderful scents, beautiful fall foliage, and jaunts to the countryside for an afternoon of apple-picking are among the joys of fall. And at the end of a trip to the orchard, we’re expected to make apple pie from the bounty we’ve just harvested.

But what if you don’t have time? What if you don’t like to bake? What if you wish you could bake an exceptional pie, but you have no idea how to do it? No worries.

If you’re like many of us here at Dandelion Chandelier, you’re a working parent or busy professional with lots of plates spinning at any given moment. And yet . . . when fall comes sweeping in and the holiday meals approach, we feel obligated to bake pie. Whether we know what we’re doing or not!

best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall 2021 holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas
Where to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

Somehow it feels obligatory to have the fragrance of an apple pie in the oven if you’re hosting for Thanksgiving. Or just back from a trip to the apple orchard with the littles.

The best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall 2021 holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas.
Where to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

The will and desire are strong – but the time and the requisite baking skills are sometimes not as . . . robust as we’d like them to be.

So is OK to cheat? Like, is it fine to buy a pie online and just heat it up?

Oh, dear reader, the answer is an emphatic yes! You do what you do well, and leave the baking to the pros. Pie is always a good idea in good times or bad – and if you’re having a slice, why not make it the best one possible?

For those times when you’re not willing or able to go the homemade route, here are 11 trusted online bakeries to turn to for the best apple pie by mail order right now.

best places to buy mail order apple pie for the holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving

1. Four and Twenty Blackbirds Salted Caramel Apple Pie.

This show-stopping apple pie from Brooklyn bakery Four and Twenty Blackbirds features hand made caramel sauce with a blend of sweet and tart apples sourced from the Hudson Valley.

BUY NOW: $42.

2. Petee’s Pie Company Hudson Valley “bake at home” apple pie.

With this scrumptious bake at home apple pie from Petee’s Pie Company in New York, you don’t even have to sacrifice the aroma of pie in the oven! An excellent way to spread some joy while resisting the temptation to spread yourself too thin.

The best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall 2021 holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

BUY NOW: $45.

3. Three Brothers Bakery Apple Pie.

Three Brothers Bakery in Houston has become famous for its pecan pie. But here’s a pro tip: their apple pie is really, really good. Think homemade cinnamon apples and a classic lattice crust sprinkled with sugar (of course). Order now for second-day delivery.

BUY NOW: $19.99.

4. Blue Owl Bakery

Missouri’s Blue Owl Bakery first opened as “From the Kitchen of Mary” in 1983. Almost forty years later, they are still going strong, shipping their signature Levee High Apple Pies ($99) by mail through Goldbelly. Piles of sweet apple encrusted in a dome of dough, caramel, and pecans: it’s apple pie nirvana.

BUY NOW – $109.

5. Tatte

One of Boston’s stellar bakeries, Tatte, is shipping their scrumptious-looking apple pie.

BUY NOW – $35. 

6. Achatz Handmade Pie Company Northern Spy Vegan Apple Pie.

Achatz Handmade Pie Company has one of the most versatile and inclusive pie menus we’ve ever seen. They offer double-crust, single-crust and vegan versions of their fruit and cream pies. This vegan apple pie made with Northern Spy apples will please everyone around the dessert buffet. BTW, there’s also an apple crumb pie that you might also want to sample.

BUY NOW: $54.

7. Bubby’s Apple Whiskey Crumble Pie.

Bubby’s in TriBeCa is the place to go in New York City for a little late-night comfort food. And now everyone can enjoy a slice of that experience themselves. Our list of where to buy apple pie online would not be complete without the pies from Bubby’s. They’re shipping their gourmet apple whiskey crumble pies via mail-order to all fifty states. So you can taste a little of that Bubby’s magic no matter where you live.


BUY NOW – $65.

8. Dangerously Delicious Pies

Baltimore is home to some pies that are… dangerously delicious. Like this classic apple pie, available on Goldbelly. The bakery was founded by a rock star (literally) and their slogan kind of says it all when it comes to those with a sweet tooth and baking aversion: “Give grandma a break and try this loaded apple pie.”

The best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall 2021 holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

BUY NOW: $65.

9. Grand Traverse Pie Company Apple Honey Pie.

This splendid apple pie from Michigan’s Grand Traverse Pie Company is sweetened only with Sleeping Bears Farms Star Thistle Honey straight from a local apiary. The serving instructions are simple: warm the pie, slice it, and then drizzle more honey on top. Roger that.

BUY NOW: $39.99.

10. Little Pie Company Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie.

This award-winning pie from New York’s Little Pie Company (it was crowned The Best Apple Pie in New York, which is saying a lot – after all, it’s the Big Apple) is the perfect finish for an autumn dinner party or a holiday meal. Or frankly for a midnight run when you just want something sweet and soothing.

The best places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall 2021 holidays, including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

BUY NOW

11. Librae Bakery Apple Cardamom Pie.

This one’s a bit of a cheat, because you can’t currently order these for shipping. But if you live in or around New York City, by all means order one and pick it up. Librae Bakery’s Apple Cardamom Pie has just a few luscious ingredients: apple spice jam; local apples; and pie crust. That works for us.

BUY NOW $40.00

where to buy apple pie online via mail order for the holidays

That’s our take on the 11 places to buy apple pie online via mail order now for the fall holidays – or really any day – including pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas. What do you think, dear reader? Lattice or crumb top? Ice cream or whipped cream? Maybe some cheddar cheese? However you choose to accessorize, just remember one of life’s simple truths: there’s never too much pie.

see luxury in a new light

Join our community! For access to insider ideas and information on the world of luxury, sign up for our Dandelion Chandelier newsletter. 

WAIT! see luxury in a new light

Join our community! For access to insider ideas and information on the world of luxury, sign up for our Dandelion Chandelier newsletter. 

get in touch

Tell us about your favorite article, any topics you would like us to cover, or how we can collaborate. We look forward to hearing from you.