Nothing says Christmas holiday better than a beautiful array of cookies, right? Lots of people will be baking their own based on beloved recipes and traditions. But for those of us who lack the skills and/or the time to do this, there’s hope. Here’s our round-up of where to buy the best mail order online gourmet Christmas holiday cookies, both sweet and savory, for Christmas 2023.
mail order gourmet holiday cookie boxes can bring the Christmas cheer
Christmas Cookies. The secret, not-so-secret best part of the holidays. Really, they’re just cookies – but once you start adding red sprinkles and cutting out snowmen, you can practically smell the mistletoe. Cookies just taste better this time of year. We don’t make the rules, we just follow them.
And of course, you may have decided to bake a round of them yourself – is anyone else following the New York Times’ 24 Days of Cookies? If you’re short on time and energy this season, though, or if you’d like to send a tin of Christmas cookies as a gift, it’s easy to outsource this particular element of holiday joy. All across the country, local artisanal bakeries have whipped up something special this season.
Here are eight top-rated cookie boxes that are available for nationwide shipping or local pickup. But beware – you’ll want to place your orders soon. They’re selling out fast.
8 holiday cookie boxes best to buy right now via mail order
1. Kemi’s Dessert Bar
New Yorkers, rejoice. Although Instagram-hit Kemi’s Dessert Bar has sold out of their shippable cookie boxes, they still have some available for local pickup. Included in the Holiday Treat Box: purple sweet potato bread, jasmine pistachio shortbread, gingerbread crinkle cookies, raspberry thumbprints, miso sesame cookies, and holiday spiced brownies – in other words, everything you could possibly want to eat this season. Order before they’re gone, and prepare to for pickup at the Lower East Side’s Canal Street Market.
BUY NOW: $55.00.
2. Magnolia Bakery
Though it may be their cupcakes and their banana pudding that put them on the map, everything at the famous Magnolia Bakery is worthy of your holiday table. You’ll want to check out the full selection, but if you’re sending a gift (or if you simply want to snack on something sweet), you can’t go wrong with the Premium Holiday Cookie Gift Tin. It has a survey of the classics: chocolate crinkles, jammy thumbprints, snowballs, and festive spritzes. It’s starting to taste a lot like Christmas!
BUY NOW: $77.00.
3. Sweet Mazie’s
Bostonians, we have a treat for you. Sweet Mazie’s specializes in glorious custom desserts, and she has a special holiday box available for local pickup this season. You’ll enjoy a set of sugar cookies, ginger cookies, chocolate peppermint cookies, chocolate covered Oreos, and white chocolate-covered pretzels. Order yours now, and then keep Mazie in mind the next time you need a custom dessert.
BUY NOW: $65.00.
4. Partybus Bakeshop
If you’re a New Yorker and you have yet to experience the joy that is Partybus Bakeshop, you are seriously missing out. But luckily, the holidays are as good as time as any to try their delicious confections for the first time – and good news, you can still try them, even if you don’t live in the area. Their fabulous cookies are available for local pickup as well as for nationwide shipping – and all your favorite players are here. Snack on some gingerbread, some peppermint surprises, some cherry pretzel shortbread, and many other sugary bites. Available as a half dozen, a dozen, and one and a half dozen.
BUY NOW: $40.00.
5. Elle’s Belles
When it comes to holiday cookies, are you the kind of person who is all gingerbread, all the way? You’ve got to check out Elle’s Belles. The Montana bakery is shipping on Goldbelly, and you can choose between their pre-made Gingerbread cookie sandwiches (with yummy cream cheese frosting), and two different DIY Gingerbread decorating kits. It’s a dessert and an activity in one.
BUY NOW: $79.95.
Do may be known for their edible cookie dough, but as you might imagine, their fully baked cookies are just as good. And their holiday box is double the fun – because it’s a decorating kit, complete with sprinkles and frosting. If you want an afternoon of cookie decorating, but without all the hard work? This is the one to order – you won’t be disappointed.
BUY NOW: $49.00.
Sweet’thing has a full range of holiday options ready for you, but if it’s holiday cookies you want, it’s holiday cookies you can get. Choose between one and a half, three, and four and a half pounds of cookies – depending on the size of your family or party (or your own appetite for holiday cookies). The cookies come in festive colors and flavors, decorated with sprinkles, and (while supplies last) topped with an adorable “winter buddy.” We can’t wait to devour these.
BUY NOW: $32.00 – $60.00.
8. Sweet Mae’s Cookies
We love Sweet Mae’s year-round, and we especially love that she’s added some holiday cookies to her shop. There are “Christmas Sprinkle Celebration,” maple ginger molasses, and peppermint bark hot cocoa cookies mixed in with the usual suspects. If you want a large, chewy cookie with some holiday cheer, these should be your go-to.
BUY NOW: $26.00.
best gourmet holiday cookie boxes to buy online right now for mail order delivery
Those are our tips on where to buy the best gourmet holiday cookie boxes, both sweet and savory, online for mail order delivery as luxury gifts for Christmas 2023. Which one’s at the top of your list, dear reader?